Expert: AI Search Is Becoming the Gatekeeper for Client Website Visibility

Writer: Jordan Sprogis

Jordan Sprogis, Contributing Expert

Jordan Sprogis is a creative writer and tech researcher who has been working on online content for the better part of a decade. She holds a bachelor's degree in professional writing from Western Connecticut State University and has devoted much of her career to crafting content for various web verticals, including CyberSpyder and The Echo. Since joining HostingAdvice, Jordan has combined her storytelling ability with her fascination for advancements in technology to pen over 500 articles geared toward industry pros and newcomers alike.

Editor: Lillian Castro

Lillian Castro, Senior Editor

Lillian Castro brings more than 30 years of editing and journalism experience to our team. She has written and edited for major news organizations, including The Atlanta Journal-Constitution and the New York Times, and she previously served as an adjunct instructor at the University of Florida. Today, she edits HostingAdvice content for clarity, accuracy, and reader engagement.

Reviewer: Cristian Lopez

Cristian Lopez, News Manager

Cristian Lopez uses his Business Marketing background from the University of Illinois at Chicago to create comfortable environments for customers, clients, and colleagues to share their thoughts and ideas openly. From interviewing tech leaders to conducting UX market research projects, Cristian knows the importance of storytelling — a key variable for innovation and inspiration. His goal at HostingAdvice is to wow readers on the ever-evolving nature of the tech industry and bring his audience the most reliable and exciting content on all things hosting.

Follow the HostingAdvice team for a daily dose of tech news, trending IT discussions, and interviews with the web's most innovative technologists.
Follow Us:
1k
1k

When we covered WP Engine’s AI agency data, the message was clear: Agencies are investing in tools, training staff, rewriting internal policies, and redesigning client sites for a web where AI is now part of the audience. But what are hosts supposed to do with this information?

Well, Liza Adams told us she may have the answer.

As an AI advisor and GTM Strategist, Adams was the keynote speaker at WP Engine’s DE{CODE} 2026 on May 6, a free virtual event built around how industries are moving into the era of the “Intelligent Web.” Her research goes straight into the question hosts should be asking: Are my clients showing up in search, and what is AI saying about them when they do?

“AI isn’t ranking your content,” Adams warned. “It’s forming an opinion about you. That’s a brand reputation problem, and treating it like a ranking problem will keep you stuck.”

AI Has Opinions Now?

To prep her DE{CODE} session, Adams ran a buyer scenario across three major AI platforms — think “what’s the best managed WordPress host for a growing eCommerce brand” — and each one returned entirely different results and described the same vendors very differently:

Asana was a top pick in ChatGPT, but its standing varied across platforms: Google AI treated it as an alternate, while Microsoft Copilot merely included it on the list.

Adams breaks it down into three pillars:

“AI pulls from sources it can read and grab quickly. If your site is hard to parse or slow to load, you won’t make the answer. Machine-readability now helps you get on the shortlist,” Adams explained.

Fast Gets You In, But Trust Gets You Picked

If more than 70% of agencies are already adjusting their development practices to better serve AI systems, hosts who aren’t thinking about this yet are already several steps behind their own customers.

No doubt does performance still matter — that’s not what Adams is saying. What she is saying is that there is a line to draw between what speed does and what trust signals do.

Agencies Are Already Building for AI

More than 70% of agencies are adjusting development practices to better serve AI systems.

70%
0%100%

“When AI gets live content to answer a question, it makes a resource-allocation decision in milliseconds. A slow or unresponsive site won’t be in the answer. There’s no SERP page 2 to fall back on,” Adams explained.

Basically, a slow site may never make it into an AI-generated answer because the system prioritizes grabbing information fast. What happens after is where hosts should be focusing.

“Beyond raw performance, AI looks for signals that say your content is worth trusting: clear authorship, transparent sources, and being backed by trusted voices,” Adams said. “AI is judging your credibility before any human reads what you wrote.”

Hosting providers should probably be having this conversation with thier clients now: Let them know that it’s not about “showing up” in SERPs anymore. Instead, it’s about trying to make sure AI understands your brand, trusts your content, and represents you accurately in SERPs/AI answers.

If Clicks Are Outdated KPIs…Then What?

There is a teeny problem for those who are used to tracking clicks: Since AI can recommend a brand before anyone even visits a site, clicks alone may not be the right KPI. This is the ROI problem that WP Engine actually flagged in our recent coverage, with 12% of agencies saying unclear returns are their biggest challenge.

Adams has some advice: “Run many structured queries across the major AI platforms and document how your brand shows up. How often does it appear? What’s said about it? How does that compare to your competitors? Do this monthly and you build a baseline.”

“Run many structured queries across the major AI platforms and document how your brand shows up. How often does it appear? What’s said about it? How does that compare to your competitors? Do this monthly and you build a baseline.”

So for example, if someone sees a brand mentioned in an AI answer, they may then search for that brand later instead of clicking directly through the AI tool at that moment.

And when users do arrive via AI-assisted search, the traffic may actually be worth more: Adams points to SEMrush data that says AI-assisted visitors convert 4.4x the rate of regular organic traffic, likely because they already have compared options before landing on your client’s site.

But if your customers still get frustrated because of their KPIs, just remember to tell them this one thing.

“If engagement and conversion on those visits are rising, you’re gaining visibility,” Adams said, “whether or not you can trace the click.”

Watch Adams’ full DE{CODE} 2026 keynote:

About the Author

Contributing Expert

Jordan Sprogis is a creative writer and tech researcher who has been working on online content for the better part of a decade. She holds a bachelor's degree in professional writing from Western Connecticut State University and has devoted much of her career to crafting content for various web verticals, including CyberSpyder and The Echo. Since joining HostingAdvice, Jordan has combined her storytelling ability with her fascination for advancements in technology to pen over 500 articles geared toward industry pros and newcomers alike.

« BACK TO: BLOG

Meet the Experts

Our team of experts with a combined 50+ years of experience in web hosting serve insight and advice to more than 20 million users!

We Know Hosting

$

4

8

,

2

8

3

spent annually on web hosting!