HostGator vs. FatCow (2016)

PJ Fancher PJ Fancher Hosting Expert
“We tested FatCow & HostGator — The winner is FatCow!”

If you’re looking for a host to grow your business or online presence with, look no further than HostGator. With an emphasis on security, server performance, and support, the team consistently brings home award after award for their reliability. Not to be outdone, FatCow has held a captivating, beginner-friendly charm in the hosting industry since 1998. With services like the “Hatchling” plan or “udderly fantastic web hosting,” how could you go wrong with either of these veteran hosts?

Advertiser Disclosure

Overall Rating
4.6/5.0 ★★★★★
Visit FatCow »
Overall Rating
4.5/5.0 ★★★★★
Visit HostGator »

Overall Hosting Comparison

Best Overall Rating

★★★★★ 4.6/5.0

Having some of the most affordable shared hosting out there, plus plenty of extras, warrants FatCow be on our list of top web hosts overall. Their customer service, performance, and focus on environmental... read more +

Having some of the most affordable shared hosting out there, plus plenty of extras, warrants FatCow be on our list of top web hosts overall. Their customer service, performance, and focus on environmental responsibility leave you feeling good about yourself and your website.

Though their hardware isn’t super modern like some of the other hosts, speeds are decent and very reliable. 24/7 phone and email support is there for you every step of the way, should you run into any issues.

Don’t be fooled by their lower price, their feature-rich offerings are adequate for many users, particularly first-timers. Website builders with eCommerce and a free domain get you started quickly and easily; unlimited disk space, bandwidth, and emails give you room to grow.

If you are looking for a low-priced web host with a good feature set and you love cow puns, look no further than FatCow.

read less -
  • FREE domain name
  • Included point-and-click website builders
  • 24/7 support
  • Unlimited disk space, bandwidth, emails, and databases
  • GREEN: Powered 100% by wind energy
  • Get started on FatCow now.
Money Back Guarantee
30 days
Disk Space
Unlimited
Domain Name
FREE (1 year)

Best Overall Rating

★★★★★ 4.5/5.0

HostGator has been around for over a decade and is well-respected for their large number of servers and their consistent reliability. Known mostly as a shared hosting provider, HostGator still supplies... read more +

HostGator has been around for over a decade and is well-respected for their large number of servers and their consistent reliability. Known mostly as a shared hosting provider, HostGator still supplies decent dedicated and VPS options if you need your site to scale.

HostGator costs a little more than some of the other budget-minded shared hosts, but that contributes to their reliability and well-known support. They offer decent features included in their basic offerings, unlimited disk space, a nice control panel, and free website templates. While the feature list is short compared to other hosts, you do get the flexibility to add them as you see fit.

Aimed primarily at the semi-technical user, HostGator's flexibility is their strong suit. Dedicated, VPS, and Windows hosting is available if that fits your needs. For those than need it, root access, SSH, and support for Ruby, Perl, Python, and other languages is available on all plans.

HostGator has nearly limitless options and control available for their server, however they require a little more knowledge than beginner-focused web hosts. If you need to host multiple sites, their wide array of offerings make them a great choice.

read less -
  • Easy-to-use control panel
  • FREE Weebly site builder
  • Unlimited disk space, emails, and bandwidth on all plans.
  • No contract required and 45-day money-back guarantee
  • 50% off your first month, plus domains starting at $5!
  • Get started on HostGator now.
Money Back Guarantee
45 days
Disk Space
Unlimited
Domain Name
New or Transfer

Cheap Hosting Comparison

Cheap Rating

★★★★★ 4.5/5.0

#7 out of 10 in Cheap Hosting reviews

FatCow is one of the better budget hosts out there. They offer great hosting features and server performance for a low price. They are also the feel-good host of the list, with a cute, pun-filled site... read more +

FatCow is one of the better budget hosts out there. They offer great hosting features and server performance for a low price. They are also the feel-good host of the list, with a cute, pun-filled site running 100% on eco-friendly wind power; however, don’t for a second think they aren’t serious about great hosting.

New users will love the inclusion of a domain name, unlimited email addresses, and a website builder with eCommerce support. Included integration with popular merchant accounts get you one step closer to selling online. All of it is wrapped up nicely in a simple-to-use control panel, cPanel.

All users will love what they call the "Script Barn," which allows for 1-click installation of popular open-source apps and scripts like WordPress, Joomla, phpBB, and more.

FatCow is a fantastic budget host, with high-budget features and flexibility with which you can easily grow your site.

read less -
  • Included domain name
  • CGI, PHP, Python, Perl, Ruby, and MySQL support
  • 1-click script installs
  • Access to website builders with eCommerce cart
  • 60% off for joining today
  • Get started on FatCow now.
Money Back Guarantee
30 days
Disk Space
Unlimited
Domain Name
FREE (1 year)

Cheap Rating

★★★★★ 4.6/5.0

#3 out of 10 in Cheap Hosting reviews

HostGator is a great compromise between performance and price. They offer unlimited emails, MySQL databases, disk space, and bandwidth, plus 1-click installs of popular open-source projects, in addition to... read more +

HostGator is a great compromise between performance and price. They offer unlimited emails, MySQL databases, disk space, and bandwidth, plus 1-click installs of popular open-source projects, in addition to a 99.9% uptime guarantee on their shared hosting plans.

HostGator’s price-to-performance perks also apply to their vast array of other hosting options, such as VPS, dedicated servers, and even reseller hosting. Their many hosting options make them a great choice for sites on the rise, in need of options for the future.

For those just getting started and looking for a good, cheap host, HostGator bundles some nice features that hosting newbies can appreciate. A very nice site builder from Weebly is included. Their control panels are also very easy to use and a free domain is a nice touch.

If you are looking for a solid web host, with a ton of flexibility, plenty of power, and great price points, you should consider making HostGator your web host of choice.

read less -
  • FREE Weebly site builder
  • Easy-to-use control panel
  • Unlimited disk, emails, and bandwidth
  • 24/7/365 premium support
  • 50% off your first month, plus domains starting at $5!
  • Get started on HostGator now.
Money Back Guarantee
45 days
Disk Space
Unlimited
Domain Name
New or Transfer

Dedicated Hosting Comparison

Dedicated Rating

★★★★ 4.3/5.0

#6 out of 7 in Dedicated Hosting reviews

If you want maximum performance and security for your site, and a host with a customer- and environmentally-friendly company, FatCow should be at the top of your list of prospective web hosts. ... read more +

If you want maximum performance and security for your site, and a host with a customer- and environmentally-friendly company, FatCow should be at the top of your list of prospective web hosts.

When it comes to dedicated hosting features, FatCow has what you should be looking for: two to four CPU cores, 4GB to 16GB RAM, tons of bandwidth, and tons of mirrored storage. They also offer all these things at a very fair rate.

What really impresses us is the many customer-first policies they have. The first that comes to mind is the "predictable pricing model," meaning they don’t financially penalize you for usage overages, nor simply shut you down. Their servers are built on cloud-based architecture, so there is always room to grow and scale with FatCow as your demands increase. Finally, their monthly billing rates are very reasonable when compared to their yearly, which is great for those who are not ready to make a long-term commitment just to save a few dollars.

read less -
  • Fully-managed servers
  • RAID 1 mirrored storage for data protection
  • Cloud-based flexibility and scalability
  • Predictable monthly costs with no overage charges
  • 3 dedicated IP addresses per plan
  • Get started on FatCow now.
Money Back Guarantee
30 days
Disk Space
500 GB - 1 TB
Domain Name
FREE (1 year)

Dedicated Rating

★★★★★ 4.5/5.0

#5 out of 7 in Dedicated Hosting reviews

Founded in 2002, HostGator is one of the largest online web hosts with a long lineage of dedicated hosting. With updated hardware, including Intel Xeon Quad core processors and lots of RAM, HostGator is a... read more +

Founded in 2002, HostGator is one of the largest online web hosts with a long lineage of dedicated hosting. With updated hardware, including Intel Xeon Quad core processors and lots of RAM, HostGator is a great balance between performance, quality, and price.

Being one of the few hosts to offer managed support and a Windows-based OS, those needing trouble-free ASP.net support should take a close look at HostGator.

HostGator boasts a top-of-the-line, fully-redundant network and datacenter, which dedicated hosting users will take full advantage of and love. They also offer a ton of IP addresses with each plan.

HostGator has a fantastic support network and 24/7 customer service in the form of phone, chat, or email. Combining that support with plenty of power, they are a very respectable choice for a dedicated host.

read less -
  • Linux or Windows servers available
  • Top of the line, fully-redundant network and datacenter
  • Unlimited MySQL databases
  • SSH access and support for multiple languages
  • Use code HA30OFF for 30% off first month
  • Get started on HostGator now.
Money Back Guarantee
N/A
Disk Space
500 GB - 1 TB RAID
Domain Name
FREE (1 year)

VPS Hosting Comparison

VPS Rating

★★★★ 4.3/5.0

#6 out of 8 in VPS Hosting reviews

FatCow offers very customer-friendly VPS plans with a lot of storage for the price. If you are looking for a reliable host, with great support and a lot of disk space, give FatCow a serious look. ... read more +

FatCow offers very customer-friendly VPS plans with a lot of storage for the price. If you are looking for a reliable host, with great support and a lot of disk space, give FatCow a serious look.

FatCow’s VPS plans are all fully-managed and come with cPanel for ease of use. They take the hassle out of installing software like Apache and MySQL and handle the hardware monitoring for you. We also appreciate the plethora of pre-installed scripts.

Arguably the most feel-good host on our list, FatCow’s datacenters and offices are 100% powered by eco-friendly wind power. They also want the best for their clients' sites and do not penalize with overage charges, should your site exceed its limits.

Founded in 1998, FatCow has been in the hosting industry for a long time. Don’t let their cheeky image throw you though; they are committed to providing excellent service and value in their hosting packages. If you are looking for a nice VPS hosting solution with a lot of storage, check FatCow Out.

read less -
  • Instantly deploy and scale
  • Predictable monthly costs with no overage fees
  • Guaranteed RAM and resources
  • Fully-managed, monitoring site load and any issues
  • Anytime money-back guarantee
  • Get started on FatCow now.
Money Back Guarantee
Anytime
Disk Space
40 GB - 120 GB
Domain Name
FREE (1 year)

VPS Rating

★★★★★ 4.5/5.0

#5 out of 8 in VPS Hosting reviews

HostGator has built a great reputation in the industry for their shared hosting options. Their VPS solutions, with optional cPanel support, provide a nice and easy introduction to those that are new to VPS... read more +

HostGator has built a great reputation in the industry for their shared hosting options. Their VPS solutions, with optional cPanel support, provide a nice and easy introduction to those that are new to VPS hosting and know their needs require more than a typical shared host.

Starting at low price points, HostGator makes transitioning to a VPS plan reasonable and doable. Each plan comes with two IPs and a bunch of storage, however their CPU and RAM offerings could be better for their respective price tags.

HostGator’s strongest point comes from their state of the art datacenter. Featuring a fully-redundant network with no single point of failure and multiple bandwidth providers, uptime should almost never be a concern.

Founded in 2002, HostGator is one of the largest online web hosts. They have more than 12,000 servers under management and award-winning support. If you are looking for a very small VPS server or value the strength of a great network, give HostGator a shot.

read less -
  • Full root access
  • Redundant network with multiple layers of network security
  • Fully- or semi-managed options
  • FREE website, domain, MySQL, and script transfer
  • Use code HA30OFF for 30% off first month
  • Get started on HostGator now.
Money Back Guarantee
45 days
Disk Space
25 GB - 3 TB
Domain Name
FREE (1 year)

WordPress Hosting Comparison

WordPress Rating

★★★★★ 4.5/5.0

#9 out of 10 in WordPress Hosting reviews

FatCow is a good, budget-minded option for those looking to host their WordPress site. With two choices (WP Starter or WP Essential), you can choose the hosting package that best fits your budget. With... read more +

FatCow is a good, budget-minded option for those looking to host their WordPress site. With two choices (WP Starter or WP Essential), you can choose the hosting package that best fits your budget. With either plan, you are offered a free domain, plus unlimited transfers and disk space, which is nice.

Their WP Essential plan, the more expensive of the two plans, benefits from an all-SSD infrastructure, which provides greater speeds than their WP Starter package. Enhanced security from SiteLock is also added, which virtually eliminates malware. 24/7 phone support is included on this plan, so if you find yourself needing a little help now and then, I would consider this package over WP Starter.

For the brave or the capable minds on a budget, the WP Starter plan may work for you. Though lacking some of the extras and support of the bigger package, their WP Starter plan is one of the least expensive WordPress hosts you can find. Both plans come with pre-installed plugins and curated themes to get your site up and running sooner.

FatCow is a great budget WordPress web hosting solution. They offer great hosting features and decent server performance for a low price.

read less -
  • Curated themes and pre-installed plugins
  • Unlimited disk Space, bandwidth, and email accounts
  • Choice of two value-based hosting packages
  • Premium plan formore speed, security, and support
  • FREE domain with registration
  • Get started on FatCow now.
Money Back Guarantee
Anytime
Disk Space
Unlimited
Domain Name
FREE (1 year)

WordPress Rating

N/A

HostGator does not currently offer this type of hosting. We would not recommend choosing this host for this hosting category.

Site Builder Hosting Comparison

Website Builder Rating

★★★★★ 4.7/5.0

#6 out of 10 in Website Builder Hosting reviews

Aimed at the low-budget customer, FatCow gets you online in only a few minutes for only a few dollars. While pretty limited at their lowest price, if you need a very simple website with only a few web... read more +

Aimed at the low-budget customer, FatCow gets you online in only a few minutes for only a few dollars. While pretty limited at their lowest price, if you need a very simple website with only a few web pages, it’s hard to argue with FatCow's value.

Using the CM4All drag-and-drop website builder, you can get a site online pretty quickly. Though their base plan is limited to only six pages, their other plans, with more support, are still very reasonable. Each plan comes with a free domain name, which saves you the trouble of purchasing one separately and waiting for name servers to propagate.

For those looking for a little more, FatCow offers support for popular blog and CMS software such as WordPress, Joomla, Drupal, and others. Integrated galleries and forums are also available. Finally, FatCow give you advertising credits towards sites like Google, Bing, and Facebook to get the ball rolling on your site’s exposure.

If you are on a budget and in need of a small, simple webpage today, with options to grow in the future, check out FatCow’s site builder offerings.

read less -
  • Easily build a 6-page site
  • CM4All drag-and-drop website builder
  • FREE domain name
  • Compatible with WordPress, Joomla, Drupal, and others
  • $250 in advertising credits
  • Get started on FatCow now.
Money Back Guarantee
30 days
Disk Space
2 GB
Domain Name
FREE (1 year)

Website Builder Rating

N/A

HostGator does not currently offer this type of hosting. We would not recommend choosing this host for this hosting category.

FatCow vs. HostGator - Our Conclusion

PJ Fancher PJ Fancher Hosting Expert
“We tested FatCow & HostGator — The winner is FatCow!”

Two farm-tastic options in web hosting, HostGator and FatCow bring a charismatic quality to hosting that’s hard to duplicate and even harder to describe. In short, FatCow is great for creating very basic websites, while HostGator brings a service you can scale and stick with long-term. If you’re a first-timer, you’ve found two fantastic options, and we wish you the best of luck in your hosting endeavors!

Overall Rating
4.6/5.0 ★★★★★
Visit FatCow »
Overall Rating
4.5/5.0 ★★★★★
Visit HostGator »